Morningstar Rating

Stock Research and Analysis

by David Whiston, CPA, CFE
With a high percentage of import and luxury brands in its sales mix, Penske Automotive Group has a strong framework for growth. The company now needs to improve its cost structure to bring margins back in line with the other public auto dealers.

Penske   Read more 

Bulls Say

Auto dealerships are stable, profitable businesses with a diversified stream of earnings coming from parts, service, and used cars.
Parts and service revenue should continue to be lucrative over time because most manufacturers require warranty work to be done at the dealership, and large dealers can more easily afford the technology and training needed to service increasingly more complex vehicles.
Penske is well-suited to acquire dealerships because automakers often require an expensive facility upgrade to approve sale of a dealership. Many smaller independent dealerships cannot afford this upgrade.
Penske is the only auto dealer to achieve a large amount of revenue diversification outside the U.S. The firm's 2002 acquisition of large U.K. dealer Sytner Group brought in $4.1 billion of revenue in 2008, up from $2.7 billion in 2005, and Sytner was recently named Dealer Group of the year in the U.K. by Motor Trader Magazine. Read more 

Bears Say

As publicly traded dealers command greater share in some markets, manufacturers may refuse to approve transfers of franchise rights at some dealerships, limiting acquisition-based growth.
New-vehicle sales in the U.S. will decline significantly this year even for the premium and foreign brands that dominate Penske's dealership ranks.
It is uncertain whether consumers will demand luxury vehicles post-recession as they have in the past. Leasing and credit may be more difficult than it was prior to the recession. Read more 

Strategy

Penske pursues acquisitions of primarily luxury dealership brands. The firm's dealers are in metropolitan areas mostly in the United States and the United Kingdom, but it also owns a handful of stores   Read more 

Management

Roger Penske, 72, has been chairman and CEO since 1999. Penske Corporation, where Roger Penske is also chairman and CEO, owns 40% of Penske Automotive Group. The next-largest shareholder is Tokyo-based Mitsui MITSY, with a 17% stake. One of Penske Automotive's   Read more 

Profile

Penske Automotive Group owns and operates 160 U.S. franchises in 17 states and 150 franchises overseas, primarily in the United Kingdom. The firm is the second-largest dealership   Read more 

First Name
Last Name
Email Address
Zip Code
Create Password
Verify Password
(6-15 characters; case sensitive)

Dollar General Stock May Lose a Few Cents 
Watch more 

View all of our analyst reports with a free trial to Morningstar.com Premium.