Morningstar Rating

Stock Research and Analysis

by David Whiston, CFA, CPA, CFE

Bulls Say

The firm's product mix, weighted toward luxury and import brands, brings more affluent consumers to the dealership, which partially mitigates the sales decline during cyclical downturns that auto sales typically experience.
Auto dealerships are moaty businesses that can maintain a narrow range of operating margins regardless of economic conditions.
Sizable dealership companies enjoy economies of scale, albeit limited ones. Read more 

Bears Say

Customers could delay maintenance or choose a cheaper independent repair shop instead of going to the dealer for servicing an older vehicle, which would negate the technological advantage that Asbury enjoys over smaller repair shops.
Overpaying for acquisitions is a risk and can lead to value destruction for investors.
The company's Q auto stand-alone used vehicle store pilot program could prove to be a waste of time and money. Read more 


Asbury's return on invested capital has comfortably exceeded its cost of capital. The company's dividend yield had been one of the highest in the auto dealer universe, but the dividend was eliminated in October 2008 because of the slowdown in earnings   Read more 


Asbury Automotive Group is a nationwide collection of automobile dealerships that went public in March 2002. The company operates 83 stores with associated parts and service   Read more 

13 New Stocks Join the Wide Moat Focus Index 
Watch more 

Premium Membership

View all of our analyst reports with a free trial to Premium.